Skip to content

We tested teeth whitening strips for 3 months — these 4 types really work

May 27, 2025
Teeth whitening strips

Teeth whitening has become a popular cosmetic treatment, with many people seeking that perfect, bright smile. However, with countless products on the market, choosing the right teeth whitening solution can be daunting. Among the various options, whitening strips have gained considerable attention for their convenience and effectiveness. But do they really work? In this article, we delve into the ins and outs of teeth whitening strips, including their efficacy, how to choose the best ones, and essential usage tips.

Understanding teeth whitening strips

Teeth whitening strips are thin, flexible pieces of plastic coated with a whitening gel that typically contains hydrogen peroxide or carbamide peroxide. These ingredients penetrate the tooth enamel to break down stains and discoloration, resulting in a brighter smile. While they can effectively reduce surface stains and lightening teeth, results vary based on the type of product used and the individual’s dental condition.

The popularity of whitening strips stems from their ease of use and affordability compared to professional dental treatments. However, it’s essential to understand that they are not a one-size-fits-all solution. Factors such as the initial condition of your teeth, your dietary habits, and your adherence to the product instructions will all influence the outcomes.

How to choose the best teeth whitening strips

When searching for the right whitening strips, several factors come into play. Here are key considerations to keep in mind:

  • ADA Seal of Acceptance: Look for products with the American Dental Association’s Seal of Acceptance, indicating the product meets safety and efficacy standards.
  • Active Ingredients: Common active ingredients include hydrogen peroxide and carbamide peroxide. These compounds are effective in breaking down stains but may not be suitable for those with sensitive teeth.
  • Concentration Levels: Higher concentrations of active ingredients typically yield faster and more noticeable results, but they may also increase tooth sensitivity.
  • Type of Strips: Some strips dissolve on the teeth, while others are removable. Consider your lifestyle when choosing—dissolvable strips are more convenient for on-the-go use.
  • Duration of Treatment: Check how long you need to wear the strips each session, as this can vary from 15 to 45 minutes depending on the brand.

How we tested teeth whitening strips

To provide you with the best recommendations, we conducted a thorough testing process. Our team used various whitening strips over a three-month period, assessing their performance based on several criteria:

  • Efficacy: We evaluated the effectiveness of each type of strip in improving tooth color and removing stains.
  • Ease of Use: The application and removal process was noted, along with how well the strips adhered and how comfortable they felt during use.
  • Coverage: Not all strips cover all teeth evenly. We assessed how well they fit different mouth shapes and sizes.
  • Side Effects: Participants reported any reactions, such as tooth sensitivity or gum irritation.
  • Taste: The flavor of the strips was considered, including any aftertaste experienced during and after use.

The best teeth whitening strips of 2025

After extensive testing, we have narrowed down the top whitening strips that stood out for their effectiveness and user satisfaction. Here are our top picks:

Best overall: Crest 3D Whitestrips Professional Effects

These strips are widely regarded as the gold standard in at-home whitening. They are accepted by the ADA and known for their strong grip and effectiveness.

  • Active ingredients: Hydrogen peroxide
  • Treatment duration: 45 minutes

Best for sensitive teeth: Lumineux Teeth Whitening Strips

Formulated without peroxides, these strips are ideal for individuals with sensitive gums. They contain natural ingredients that help whiten teeth without causing irritation.

  • Active ingredients: Plant-based extracts
  • Treatment duration: 30 minutes

Best professional-grade: Opalescence Go Prefilled Whitening Trays

For those seeking stronger results, these prefilled trays utilize a professional-grade whitening gel. They cover all teeth evenly and require less time to achieve noticeable results.

  • Active ingredients: Hydrogen peroxide
  • Concentration: 15%
  • Treatment duration: 15 to 20 minutes

Best dissolvable: Moon Oral Beauty Midnight Enamel Care Dissolving Whitening Strips

Perfect for travel, these dissolvable strips are easy to use and contain ingredients that protect and restore enamel.

  • Active ingredients: Hydrogen peroxide
  • Treatment duration: 15 minutes

How to use teeth whitening strips correctly

To maximize the effectiveness of whitening strips, follow these essential guidelines:

  1. Read and adhere to the manufacturer’s instructions closely. Overuse can lead to tooth sensitivity.
  2. Apply the strips to clean and dry teeth. Brushing beforehand can enhance results, but do not brush immediately before application to avoid sensitivity.
  3. Avoid staining foods and drinks, like coffee or red wine, for at least 24 hours post-treatment.
  4. Consider using additional whitening products, such as toothpaste or gels, to maintain results between treatments.

Frequently asked questions about teeth whitening strips

As you navigate the world of teeth whitening strips, you may have some common questions:

  • Do teeth whitening strips really work? Yes, they can lighten teeth by a few shades, but results are not permanent and may fade over time.
  • How do they work? Whitening strips use bleaching agents to penetrate enamel and remove stains. Over-the-counter versions typically have lower concentrations than professional treatments.
  • How often should I use them? Most brands recommend daily use for about two weeks, then periodic maintenance as needed.
  • Can they damage teeth? Incorrect use can cause damage. Always follow instructions and discontinue use if discomfort occurs.
  • Why do my gums hurt when using strips? Whitening agents can irritate gums if they come into contact. Professional treatments mitigate this risk better than at-home options.

Meet our experts

To ensure the information provided is accurate and reliable, we consulted dental professionals with extensive experience in cosmetic dentistry:

  • Dr. Erin Fraundorf, a dentist at Boca Orthodontic and Whitening Studio.
  • Dr. David Wagner, a cosmetic dentist at Pinar & Wagner Dental Office.

Why trust our recommendations?

Our recommendations are backed by extensive testing and the expertise of dental professionals. By collaborating with experts and conducting thorough evaluations, we aim to provide you with objective and practical advice on achieving a brighter smile.